What does Tai Chi look like in a fight?
Submitted by GrahamB on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 7:34am.
in
Following on from my last post (Push hands is not fighting) it's time to ask the next logical question. What is? What's a "fight" supposed to look like if you do Tai Chi? It's an interesting question, and to some extent I'm thinking out loud here, so please bear with me. Practicing applications from the form to work on your technique is fair enough, but when it comes to actually applying your art in a free situation against a resisting opponent what would it look like? Would you expect to see picture perfect Single Whip poses? Brush knee poses? Some people would say yes.
What should Style X "look like" in a real fight? If unique training methods with a history (obviously it's not always a current reality) of martial effectiveness don't produce an identifiable expression under pressure in a fight . . . then what are they for?
On video
Let's take a step back and review the evidence. Historically there have been a few examples of respected Tai Chi practitioners taking challenges that have been captured on film. Take Wu Gongyi (Wu style Tai Chi Chuan) fighting Chan Hakfu (White Crane stylist) for charity in Macau, as an example. What did that look like? See here:
It didn't look much like what you'd expect "Tai Chi" to look like, did it?
Perhaps the 'top' public face of Tai Chi is the current Chen Grandmaster, Chen Xiaowang. Here's how he looks doing Tai Chi applications:
There are no clips of him free fighting on YouTube, but here's how he looks when faced with a non-compliant opponent doing push hands:
Again, it didn't look much like what you'd expect Tai Chi to look like, did it? What did you expect it to look like?
Breaking it down
Tai Chi practitioners, regardless of style, have 3 things in common:
1) Form. All Tai Chi styles have a form - a set sequence of flowing movements that occupies the bulk of their practice time.
2) Push hands. All Tai Chi styles has a form of push hands exercise.
3) Applications. All Tai Chi styles of applications to movements in the form, which are often applies as stand-alone applications or in a push hands setting.
So how do you translate those 3 things into a fighting art? There are 2 common solutions I've seen people come up with to work out how you're actually meant to fight with Tai Chi. These are:
1) Ignore fighting altogether. This is by far the most popular choice, and it's often what people are doing without realising it when they think they are learning a martial art. Stick to doing 1-2 applications, drills and push hands. This, apparently, will prepare you for using the art freely. You are never pushed outside your comfort zone, so you never 'lose' or get defeated. Too much training in this zone only gives rise to the ideas of what Tai Chi "should" look like in a fight.
2) Train for competition. Cardio, pad work, bag work. Practice techniques over and over - set response to things happening - he does X so I counter with Y. Here the form takes a back seat and becomes something of a cool-down or wind down exercise performed after the hard physical training. But what about the idea of Tai Chi? Of balancing Yin and Yang. Yin becomes block and Yang becomes punch.
A better way, I think, lies somewhere between these two extremes.
When people try to fight with Tai Chi as if it were a technique-orientated art it just ends up being... nothing like Tai Chi. Tai Chi techniques certainly work, but they are more like examples to study principles through, rather than things to try in a fight. What Tai Chi really is is 1) a collection of physical principles of movement and 2) a strategy. Both need to work together for it to be "Tai Chi Chuan". The physical principles revolve around being balanced, integrated, co-ordinated and centred in motion, while the strategy revolves around yielding to force and following the opponent. Those are simple, but profound truths and all found in the Tai Chi classics.
But still the question arrises - what would it look like? The problem is those "internal" aspects are things that are hard to see on the outside. More technique-orientated arts will have a particular look or style to them when used for real. A properly trained boxer, for example, will look like a boxer. Tight guard, recogniseable hooks and jabs. You can expect a Capoeiraist to come out with a few spinning kicks. The techniques are part of the art. That's simply not true for Tai Chi.
This is the big problem with Tai Chi - where does the beginner start? A beginner needs something tangible to latch on to. Abstract concepts don't help. Some Tai Chi styles solve this problem by teaching basic San Shou or kickboxing-like techniques to beginners. Something solid for them to grasp before higher principles are introduced. That approach makes sense to me. My own teacher has a similar approach, which is to use Choy Lee Fut as a base style on which to build your fighting technique first before switching over to the Tai Chi principles and strategy later in your training. Of course, if you say you do this then immediately you can be criticised for being "not pure Tai Chi", but the result seems to be something that actually works - an art you can use for real. Of course, the danger is that you get too good at the 'base art' and never have the need to develop the higher principles fully. But what's the alternative? Seriously, I don't think there is one. You're best off learning a simpler art first, then basing your Tai Chi on that.
The Buddha likened his teachings to a raft. It helped you get across the river, but once you were across you were meant to abandon the raft.
- GrahamB's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Beautiful blog with great
Beautiful blog with great informational content. Mostly certifications related and tai chi look like in a fight related topics are really very good. 220-602, PMI-001 and 642-892 are also good topics. Thanks for this great sharing.
Beautiful blog with great
asef
Beautiful blog with great
Beautiful blog with great informational content. Mostly certifications related and Tai Chi look related topics are really very good. 70-290 braindump, 70-290 latest dumps and braindumps 70-562 are also good topics. Thanks for this great sharing.
Sima Qian wrote how Lao-zi
Sima Qian wrote how Lao-zi once met with Confucius, whom he criticized for pride and ambition. However, Confucius told his disciples, "I know how birds can fly, how fish can swim, how animals can run. Yet the runner may be trapped; the swimmer may be hooked; and the flyer may be shot by an arrow. But who knows how dragons ride on winds through clouds into heaven? Today I have seen Lao-zi and can compare him only to a dragon ccent practice exam."
iphone life Saudi Arabia healthy diet SEO Company Promotional Products
You have a great vision. I
You have a great vision. I do not agree 646-985 with all you stated, but your thoughts are definitely interesting and worth reading 646-671 keep up doing good job. I truly appreciate your way of presenting such an excellent suggestion. I want more 646-563 and i will come back here to see more updates in future 646-656 as well.my best wishes for you always so keep it up.regards
Ads by google
The Gucci company has undergone a makeover,Gucci Shoes taekn on a line of green products including bags and gucci shoes men wrappings for their products and boxes for their Gucci shoes.gucci men shoes What do you think about Gucci's efforts to go green? I wonder if the cost of the new Tiffany Jewellery products will be reflected in Gucci's prices?
links of london
Gucci online shop. We
Gucci online shop. We Provide Discount Gucci Bags,Gucci Handbags,Gucci Shoes and Gucci Wallets. gucci bags gucci handbags gucci jewelry gucci Cheap and Discount Gucci Handbag or Wallet Gucci Handbags is your best Gucci Bag provider gucci sale gucci shoes cheap gucci shoes gucci shoes sale gucci men shoes gucci shoesn,cheap gucci shoes , Gucci established itself as a luxury fashion label in the clothing, accessories and jewelry field. he quality of their fabrics and materials made Gucci the symbol of Made in Italy.
What does Tai Chi look like in a fight?
Re: What does Tai Chi look like in a fight?
I enjoyed reading about Tai Chi Kongfu. I need to read more on this topic...I admiring time and effort you put in your blog, because it is obviously one great place where I can find lot of useful info.. Excell Pressure Washer, Husky 1750 power washer, Campbell Hausfeld electric pressure washer.
Regards,
James
converse shoes
Converse all stars
visvim folk
buy converse boots
Visvim christo
converse chucks
Converse sneakers
pink converse
visvim online
all star shoes
converse all star shoes
Emu boots
visvim shoes
Converse on stars
Converse leather
Converse all star
emu australia boots
Visvim
Converse boots
Converse chuck taylor
Converse shoes
Converse all stars
converse chucks taylor
Visvim fbt
Converse double tongue
Converse one star
Converse Uk shop
visvim hockney
discount converse
converse outlet
converse store
Converse Weapon
converse all star shoes
all stars shoes
chucks shoes
chuck taylor shoes
converse chucks
converse store
Converse Weapon
converse all star shoes
all stars shoes
chucks shoes
chuck taylor shoes
emu sheepskin boot
converse black boots
Converse official website
visvim hockney
converse high tops
Emu Snow boots
chuck taylor converse
pink converse
emu sheepskin
Converse on stars
Converse leather
visvim hockney
converse chucks
converse shoes outlet
Converse shop
emu stinger boots
converse black bootss
chuck taylor converse
wow gold
With the conspiracy wow gold world of warcraft goldand revengewow gold world of warcraft gold wow gold kaufen wow gold kaufen wow gold wow gold that unwindsbuy wow gold buy wow gold wow power leveling, the worldwow power levelingwow cd key wow cd key needs a little cheap wow gold cheap wow gold preaching on tolerance.
Some merchants who sell
Some merchants who sell replica watchesa lot of fine wine have taken it into their fake watches own hands to ascertain authenticity.fake rolex English wine merchant Corney and Barrow replica rolex claims to have written and photographic records of every surviving Petrus produced since breitling 1964 and uses these along with tell-tale signs on the cork, bottle and label to authenticate the wine.
chateaux liberally opened
chateaux liberally opened old replica watches wines, topped them off and recorked them fake watches with a fresh cork!Of late, we are seeing sophisticated fake rolex methods of ascertaining a bottle’s contents. replicaFrench scientists suggested using a particle accelerator to measure the radiation emitted when a wine bottle is placed under an ion beam.
Step around burgers, put
Step around burgers, put away chicken; to grills something that could be genuinely rapidly foodstuff, think portable charcoal bbq grill about that fish filet within the filet mignon.
A lot of chefs forget fish whenever they take out their own charcoal barbecue grill, favoring the actual classic beef and pork. Unfortunately grilling fish releases fillets which might extremely kamado grill flaky along with flavorful, a person wouldn't think twice about barbecue grill not often known the very beer batter or maybe typically the profound baking.
Grilled fish is actually healthful - virtually fat-free outdoor barbecue grill help save a little brushing of vegetable oil to prevent it from inserting -- plus making that at real wood cedar planks can kamado grills certainly add full flavour free of improving unhealthy calories.
Karen Adler along with Judith Fertig, the making duo by Kansas referred to as typically the kamado ceramic grill Queens, reported ample at home cooks, particularly landlocked Midwesterners, skip fish relating to grill together with are usually surprised to find out barbecue grills how very easy it is without question.
With every, Adler plus Fertig bbq grills possess created much more when compared with 20 cookbooks, primarily on grilling in barbecue grill accessories addition to barbecuing, this includes the particular recently launched "Techniques with regard to Cooking charcoal bbq grill Fish" and also "Skills intended for Planking"
"I consider the way to grilling fish is to cedar plank this," Adler kamado ceramic grill stated. Planking, or maybe making on a fabulous cedar planks of savoury solid wood which has been grill bundles soaked in water, helps to continue to keep fish succulent plus reduces the call to turn the actual fish filet over, extremely firmly sticking isn't a concern. Fish with the latest planks chefs by means of portable outdoor grill roundabout temperature. You need to soak the exact cedar in cold water for not less than one hour before putting this about typically the grill so the plank doesn't burn during cooking.
Planking occurs in convenient pertaining to extremely thin fillets of water fish, this sort of since perch, which in turn can certainly sink while outdoor bbq grills. Whenever it's done preparing food, the fish bbq smokers is good straight out of the cedar.Aluminum foil likewise helps out lining the particular bbq grill grates and also generating packets to get fish.
While with regard to the time to barbeque grill fish, Adler charcoal grills as well as Fertig advise a very simple "10 minutes of the inch of thickness" rule, turning over at the particular halfway point. A good salmon fillet that calculates 3/4 -inch-thick will likely barbeque smoker grill need to barbeque grill about 7 to 8 minutes, or simply bbq grill approximately 4 minutes upon each side over high, direct heat.Nearly every type of fish and also shellfish may be
bbq grill smoker cooked upon the exact grilling.
ugg boots
For the past replica watches more than replica watches 100 years, the worldwide famous Swiss watch manufacturing brand Rolex has been the most prestigious and most excellent brand in the business of watch replica watches making industry replica watches in the global. Rolex has always standing at the cutting edge of the innovative watch creation and has set the bar so high for the watch making industry that other watch brands replica handbags throughtout the replica handbags world have always found themselves chasing this very prestigious brand to match its height. Over the years, Rolex Louis Vuitton has continually Louis Vuitton created a large amount of watch lines. Yacht-Master is one of the new creations to the family ugg boots that has ugg boots gained magnificent popularity worldwide.
They are designed to hamper
They are designed to hamper the virus' replication in cells, thus buying time for the immune system to mount replica watches a response replica watches and crush the invader. The research was conducted by the US Army Medical Research Institute replica watches of Infectious replica watches Diseases in collaboration with a Washington-based biotech firm, AVI BioPharma, and was revealed replica handbags in the journal replica handbags Nature Medicine. The Pentagon pumped funding into research for a vaccine and treatment for Ebola-type viruses in the wake of the September 9, 2001, terror attacks on the United States. For filoviruses are on the list of Louis Vuitton pathogens such Louis Vuitton as anthrax that are considered tempting sources for biological warfare or terrorism. An important step in combatting ugg boots Ebola was ugg boots announced in May this year, again using tests on lab monkeys but involving a somewhat different technique to disrupt viral replication.
replica watches
Since time began, the earth's replica watches only satellite replica watches, the moon has both fascinated and intrigued mankind causing strange replica handbags phenomena and replica handbags setting the rhythm of our daily lives. Perrelet, pioneer in the development of ugg boots the perpetual ugg boots movement since 1777, captures the course of the moon and allows the wearer to follow replica watches its evolution replica watches on one's wrist with its unique Big Central Moonphase ugg boots timepiece which ugg boots blends inspiration with extreme precision.All of replica watches the fake replica watches Movado watches have one thing in common-their spectacular design. These watches are well known over the world for their dial without any numbers or markings. The only give away is a diamond at 12 o'clock, and the Movado replica watches engraving in replica watches small letters at 6 o'clock.
replica watches
Since time began, the earth's replica watches only satellite replica watches, the moon has both fascinated and intrigued mankind causing strange replica handbags phenomena and replica handbags setting the rhythm of our daily lives. Perrelet, pioneer in the development of ugg boots the perpetual ugg boots movement since 1777, captures the course of the moon and allows the wearer to follow replica watches its evolution replica watches on one's wrist with its unique Big Central Moonphase ugg boots timepiece which ugg boots blends inspiration with extreme precision.All of replica watches the fake replica watches Movado watches have one thing in common-their spectacular design. These watches are well known over the world for their dial without any numbers or markings. The only give away is a diamond at 12 o'clock, and the Movado replica watches engraving in replica watches small letters at 6 o'clock.
are replica omega
are replica omega temperamenteritable replica handbags centenary replica iwc brand. Today, just mention replica tag heuer crystal products, the experts replica breitling think the first one replica rolex brand is Swarovski. Swarovski jewelry luxury rolex and fake louis vuitton imitated crystal gucci handbags at the top, the senior hublot replica industry replica gucci prestigious jewelry hublot replica products.
AbercrombieThe developers
AbercrombieThe developers are so Abercrombie & fitch productive and competent that they can quickly foresee the desires and high demand in the clients, dependant on the today's designer field. The way, this brand provides theAbercromb & fitch needs of its consumers is abercrombie and fitch completely extensive. The customers sense greatly regarded by buying fitch clothing the garments, for they've entire trust and confidence that the products, fitch clothingwhich they've picked up fromthe sites of this brand, is surely about to suit and fitch clothing and you will be really durableabercrombie and fitch clothing. To buy even a single means that you must abercrombie and fitch abercrombie and fitch clothing amount from your wallets, but following donning and fitch clothing that shirt, you are surely about to really feel which you have invested in prudently and worthily.
abercrombie new,
ambercrombie,
abercrombie et fitch,
abercombrie fitch,
mens leather thongs,
clothes sale,
abercrombie men,
ambercombie and fitch,
hollister clothing sale,
abercrombie and fitch shirts,
abercrombie&fitch,
abercrombie fitch shop,
men abercrombie,
abercrombie shop，
abercrombiestore，
abercrombie london，
abercrombie uk ，
Abercrombie outlet ，
abercrombie and fitch uk ，
abercrombie fitch uk，
Abercrombie & fitch uk，
abercrombiekids
` Women in summer would
`
Women in summer would like to become beautiful. Everything can grab other's eyes is their best friends.Products make them beauty and confident is their favourite. Look in the street,you can see many different types of make up to show women's personality.
Welcome to the shop, the following is our products, free shipping.
Soccer Shoes Cheap Soccer Shoes Nike Soccer Shoes Adidas Soccer Shoes Nike Soccer Shoes sale Adidas Soccer Shoes sale UGG UGGs UGG Boot UGG Boots UGG Boots Sale Cheap UGG Boots UGG Boots Cheap Women UGG boots ugg boots cardy ugg cardy boots Timberland Timberland sale Timberland boots Timberland boots online Timberland on sale New timberland boots UGG UGG boots UGG boots sale UGG boots short Short ugg Short ugg boots Ugg boots tall Nike Air Nike Air Max Nike Air Max Shoes Nike SB Nike Dunk Nike Dunk SB Nike Dunk SB Shoes Nike Shox Nike Shox Shoes Women Bags Women Bags Sale Women Handbags Women Handbags Sale Women New Bags Cheap Bags Cheap Bags On Sale New women bags New women bags sale New women bags sale online Louis Vuitton Handbags Gucci bags Nike Nike Shoes Nike Shoes Sale Nike running Nike running shoes Nike trainers Nike trainers shoes Timberland Timberland boots Timberland boots sale Timberland boot Timberland boot sale Timberland boots cheap Men timberlands MBT MBT Shoes MBT Chapa GTX MBT Men Shoes MBT Women Shoes Discount MBT Shoes LV Handbags Gucci Handbags Chanel Handbags Chloe Handbags D&G Handbags Dior Handbags Fendi Handbags Hermes Handbags Jimmy Choo Bags Marc Jacobs Bags Miu Miu Handbags Mulberry Bags Prada Handbags Versace Handbags Yves Saint Laurent Balenciaga Bags Burberry Handbags LV Handbags Gucci Handbags Chanel Handbags Chloe Handbags D&G Handbags Dior Handbags Fendi Handbags Hermes Handbags Jimmy Choo Bags Marc Jacobs Bags Miu Miu Handbags Mulberry Bags Prada Handbags Versace Handbags Yves Saint Laurent Balenciaga Bags Burberry Handbags
Those who want to become most beautiful in the world should try them. Just ones can make you different. Girls who want to grab your boyfriends's heart is necessary to use them.
asics shoes
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Black
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Black Gold
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Black Red
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Brown Beige
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Gold Black
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 White Pink
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 White Purple
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 White
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 White Yellow
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Yellow Black
Onitsuka Tiger Ultimate 81 Black Purple
Onitsuka Tiger Ultimate 81 Black White
Onitsuka Tiger Ultimate 81 Grey White
Onitsuka Tiger Rotation 77 Black White
Onitsuka Tiger Rotation 77 Brown Gold
Onitsuka Tiger Rotation 77 Gold Black
Onitsuka Tiger Rotation 77 White Green
Onitsuka Tiger California 78 Black White
Onitsuka Tiger California 78 Grey Brown
Onitsuka Tiger California 78 Grey Green
Onitsuka Tiger Seck Lo Black Orange
Onitsuka Tiger Seck Lo Black Red
Onitsuka Tiger Seck Lo Brown Beige
onitsuka tiger fabre Blue Red
Asics Revolve Le Black Gray
Asics Revolve Le Yellow Green
Asics Top Seven Black Silver
Onitsuka Tiger Coolidge Lo White Black
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 Lauta White
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico Mid Runner Black Silver
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico Mid Runner Black White
Onitsuka Tiger Mexico Mid Runner White
Onitsuka Tiger Mini Coope Beige Brown
Onitsuka Tiger Olympos Blue White
replica watches
In the large family replica watches of watch replica watches collections of the famous watch company Bell & Ross, there replica handbags are, surelyreplica handbags , quite a lot excellent models that are created by this ugg boots watch maker ugg boots. However, the Bell & Ross BR 01 Tourbillon replica watches Phantom is replica watches, actually, the first tourbillon watch model by the company. It provides a visual complication ugg boots that matches ugg boots with Bell & Ross philosophy of technical and professional demands. It offers replica watches readability replica watches, performance, precision and water-resistance with a sporty look.The uniqueness of this timepiece is its titanium and carbon fibre desk/table support that enables replica watches it to be replica watches positioned in a static vertical position, and thereby the existence of the tourbillon is justified.
hi
Thanks for this great post - I will be sure to check out your blog more often
Acai Berry Diet
Stretch Mark Removal
How To Get Pregnant
Diet Solution Program
Diet Solution Program
Cut Your Own Hair
Timberland boots
Through timberland work boot discoverd unhealthy for human, doctors can not find out any problem in Timberland. It sounds like that it has no problem. Really is. Timberland is famous for it's high quality and comfortable feeling, with 6-inch high heel and bold design, Timberland has changed its mind to adjust summer. Good air permeability can protect your feet dry, high quality leather can make your boots without odor. Keep belence and resist to make people healty are the purpose of Timberland. Timberland company's credo is to create excellence to design the world's most innovative products. Timberland Mens Work Boots 6 inch chestnut come with different styles from timberland roll top boots . Timberland Chukka boots is very strong, durable, can withstand years of use. In addition waterproof very good, it can keep feet dry in any weather. Chukka-style Boots are the perfect all-around outdoor footwear, and Timberland has been doing them the right way since 1973. The full black Timberland Womens Roll top Boots white ideal for outdoor sports, its appearance has been welcomed by many consumers.Most of the current Timberlands retain some of the original flavor as they include sheepskin in one way or another. Leather boots are great for all year round usage, as fleecy fibers inside the boot keep feet warm, while still encouraging air circulation. The only time when it is perhaps inadvisable to wear Timberland Womens Roll top Boots white is during rainy weather. However a gentle wash (not in the washing machine) with cool water should ensure any problems with mud are easily solved. When choosing which boots to buy, it is important to look at a variety of retailers, as prices can vary wildly.In fact, Timberland boots are again commonly referred to as "timberland chukka boots", they are not that pretty but you can say that you'll love them once you wear them Timberlands are perfect in both warm and cold climates, made of 100 percent sheepskin that will keep your feet dry and comfortable. Timberlands are available in your nearest stores and online shopping websites. Originally trademarked in America but sold to an American company making it recognized all over the world. http://www.timberlandworkboot.com/
perfect rolex replica watches free shipping
I bought a perfect replica submariner watch from Replica Watches Store just cost me $80 with Free Shipping option
There you can buy all submariner series watch with very low prices, such as Rolex Submariner Replica watches includes Rolex Submariner Date Replicas, Rolex Submariner 16610 Replicas, Rolex Submariner 50th anniversary Replicas, Rolex Submariner Green, Rolex Submariner Blue, Rolex Submariner Full Gold, Rolex Submariner Ceramic Bezel Watches, rolex series includes
Fake Rolex Replicas,
Rolex Daytona,
Rolex oyster perpetual DateJust
Breitling watches, includes
Breitling for Bentley,
Breitling Navitimer